Stop Measuring Products. Start Measuring What Changed for the Member.
- Anne Legg
- 5 days ago
- 5 min read
Credit unions measure a lot.
Loans originated.
Accounts opened.
Deposits gathered.
Credit cards activated.
Products per member.
Digital adoption.
Delinquencies.
Net promoter scores.
These are important measures. They tell us how the credit union is performing.
But there's another question we don't ask nearly enough:
What changed for the member?
A $25,000 auto loan originated is a transaction.
A member who now has reliable transportation to get to work is an outcome.
A savings account opened is a transaction.
A member who moves from $100 to $500 in emergency savings is an outcome.
A debt consolidation loan booked is a transaction.
A member who has $300 more available each month because expensive debt was restructured is an outcome.
We've become very good at measuring what members do with the credit union.
It's time to get better at measuring what the credit union does for the member.
Outputs aren't outcomes
This distinction matters.
Suppose your credit union originates 5,000 auto loans this year.
That's an impressive production number.
It tells leadership about lending volume, revenue and market performance.
But it doesn't tell us what changed in the lives of those 5,000 members.
Did they replace unreliable transportation?
Did their monthly transportation costs decrease?
Did refinancing create additional household cash flow?
Did access to reliable transportation allow someone to get to work consistently?
Those are very different questions.
They're also much closer to the reason credit unions exist.
Consider the savings account
We celebrate when members open savings accounts.
And we should.
But opening the account is only the beginning of the story.
Imagine two credit unions each open 1,000 new savings accounts.
Twelve months later, Credit Union A reports:
1,000 savings accounts opened.
Credit Union B reports:
1,000 savings accounts opened.
420 members who previously had less than $400 in accessible savings now have more than $400.
310 of those members have maintained that cushion for at least six months.
Same product.
Very different understanding of impact.
Credit Union A measured activity.
Credit Union B began measuring progress.
Now imagine doing this across the member's financial life
This is the idea behind CU Power.
Rather than defining success solely through product performance, what if credit unions also measured whether members were becoming financially stronger?
CU Power looks at seven dimensions of a member's financial life:
Transportation Access & Reliability
Can members access and maintain reliable transportation?
Housing & Shelter Stability
Are members better positioned to maintain stable housing?
Emergency Savings Stability
Are members building and maintaining an accessible financial cushion?
Debt Resilience & Management
Is debt becoming more manageable rather than simply moving from one lender to another?
Retirement Readiness
Are members building toward longer-term financial security?
Credit Health Improvement
Is the member's credit position improving over time?
Financial Confidence
Does the member actually feel more capable of managing their financial life?
Suddenly, we're measuring something much closer to the credit union mission.
This changes the questions leadership asks
Traditional reporting might tell leadership:
Auto loan production increased 8%.
An impact-oriented conversation asks:
How many members improved their transportation situation because of us?
Traditional reporting says:
Savings deposits increased $12 million.
An impact-oriented conversation asks:
How many more members now have an emergency cushion than they did a year ago?
Traditional reporting says:
We refinanced $20 million in consumer debt.
An impact-oriented conversation asks:
How much monthly financial capacity did we return to those members?
Traditional reporting says:
Our members have an average of 3.4 products with us.
An impact-oriented conversation asks:
Are members with deeper relationships actually becoming financially stronger?
That's a different conversation.
And I believe it's one credit union boards and leadership teams increasingly need to have.
This isn't about abandoning traditional metrics
Credit unions still need to measure ROA.
Loan growth matters.
Deposit growth matters.
Efficiency matters.
Capital matters.
Delinquency matters.
Products matter.
The institution has to remain financially strong to fulfill its mission.
But those measures answer:
Is the credit union healthy?
They don't necessarily answer:
Are our members becoming healthier because we're here?
We need both.
Because a financially strong credit union with no evidence of member impact is only telling half of its story.
Start with what you can measure
This doesn't require every credit union to build a sophisticated data environment tomorrow.
In fact, I think that's where many data initiatives go wrong.
We start with the technology.
The warehouse.
The platform.
The dashboard.
The AI strategy.
Instead, start with a question.
What do we want to know about the financial lives of our members?
Then determine whether the data needed to answer that question already exists.
For some credit unions, the first measure might be emergency savings.
For another, it might be transportation.
For another, debt stress.
For another, paycheck-to-paycheck behavior.
You don't need to measure everything on day one.
Measure one thing that matters.
Establish the baseline.
Take action.
Measure it again.
Because the second measurement changes everything
Imagine your credit union discovers:
42% of active members have less than $400 in accessible emergency savings.
That's insight.
You create an initiative designed to help those members build savings.
Twelve months later:
35% are below $400.
That's progress.
Then you identify the members who participated in the credit union's intervention and discover they improved at a meaningfully higher rate.
Now you're getting closer to impact.
That progression matters:
We saw something.
We did something.
Something changed.
We can measure the difference.
That's the foundation of proof.
Imagine what this does to the credit union story
Think about the annual report.
Instead of only:
We originated $350 million in loans.
Imagine adding:
2,400 members improved their transportation access.
Instead of only:
Deposits grew 7%.
Imagine:
1,800 members built their emergency savings above $400.
Instead of only:
We refinanced $18 million in consumer debt.
Imagine:
Members saved an estimated $1.2 million annually in debt payments, creating additional household financial capacity.
Those numbers tell a different story.
To members.
To employees.
To boards.
To regulators.
To lawmakers.
To communities.
They don't simply say:
We're different.
They begin to answer:
What difference did we make?
This may be the next evolution of the credit union movement
Credit unions were created to improve people's financial lives.
That mission hasn't changed.
But the environment around us has.
Affordability is squeezing household budgets.
Members can earn more and still lose financial capacity.
A $400 expense can expose how little cushion many households have.
And the financial signals telling us those things may increasingly be visible in the data members generate every day.
So perhaps the opportunity isn't to create another financial wellness program.
Perhaps it's to change what we measure.
Don't stop measuring loans.
Measure what the loan made possible.
Don't stop measuring deposits.
Measure whether the member became more resilient.
Don't stop measuring products.
Start measuring progress.
Because ultimately, the most powerful measure of a credit union isn't how many products a member has.
It's whether that member is financially stronger because the credit union exists.
That's the shift from activity to outcomes.
From mission to measurable impact.
And that's CU Power.
Click 👆🏻 on the image to schedule a conversation to learn more.
Credit unions do meaningful work every day—but those stories often live in silos.
CU Power Points is a living collection of impact moments that make the value of credit unions easier to see, reflect on, and learn from.
👉 Explore CU Power Points. Submit your own!
Your Board. Your Strategy. Future-Ready.
The future of credit unions is data-driven—and that future begins in the boardroom. THRIVE’s Board Strategy Workshops help unlock alignment and accelerate your leadership’s journey toward impactful decisions. These customized sessions guide boards beyond passive oversight into confident enablers of innovation, simplifying AI and analytics for real-world applications.
If your leadership is ready to shift from “data stuck” to “data smart”—fast—this is for you. Curious? Let’s build your next board strategy together. Learn more here.
Comments