Relevance Is the Real Risk: Why Credit Unions Must Prove What Would Be Lost
- Anne Legg
- 4 days ago
- 4 min read
The Silent Risk Facing the Movement
For decades, the cooperative model has delivered meaningful value to members and communities. The mission has always been clear: improve financial lives.
But in a world increasingly defined by data, transparency, and measurable outcomes, mission alone is no longer enough.
Good intentions are not evidence.
Anecdotes are not proof.
History is not immunity.
In boardrooms, regulatory conversations, legislative debates, and even among younger consumers, a silent question now exists:
If credit unions disappeared tomorrow, could we clearly demonstrate what would be lost?
Not emotionally.
Not historically.
Not philosophically.
But measurably.
This is not a crisis of performance. It is a crisis of translation.
Credit unions are doing meaningful work every day. But the industry lacks a shared, modern way to consistently translate that work into measurable, defensible outcomes.
Without that translation, purpose remains aspirational.
And relevance becomes fragile.
Consolidation Is a Signal
Consolidation is often framed as an operational solution.
But across industries, consolidation accelerates when:
Differentiation weakens
Value propositions blur
Institutions struggle to justify independence
Consolidation is often a symptom — not a strategy.
When institutions cannot clearly articulate and demonstrate their distinct impact, scale becomes the default defense.
The cooperative model was never built on scale.
It was built on purpose.
And purpose, in this moment, must become measurable.
The Measurement Question We Have Avoided
Credit unions measure what they manage.
Loan growth.
Deposit growth.
ROA.
Delinquency.
Efficiency.
These are necessary.
But they do not answer the deeper question:
Are members’ financial lives becoming more stable, resilient, and confident because we exist?
If relevance is to be defensible, the industry must anchor itself in outcomes that reflect lived financial conditions — not just financial transactions.
So what should credit unions actually be measuring?
The Seven Outcomes That Define Financial Stability
If we step back from products and look at people, seven foundational conditions consistently determine whether households and communities thrive.
Credit unions should be able to measure whether they are improving:
1. Transportation Access and Reliability
Can members reliably access work, healthcare, and essential services?
Without transportation stability, income stability erodes.
2. Housing and Shelter Stability
Can members afford and sustain secure housing?
Housing is not just an expense — it is the foundation of financial and personal well-being.
3. Emergency Savings Stability
Do members have sufficient short-term savings to absorb financial shocks?
Savings is the pivot point between resilience and crisis-driven borrowing.
4. Debt Stress, Resilience, and Management
Can members manage and recover from debt without chronic financial strain?
This goes beyond credit score to actual recovery capacity.
5. Retirement and Long-Term Security
Are members progressing toward long-term financial independence and dignity?
Retirement readiness reflects long-term financial capability.
6. Credit Health Improvement
Are members gaining sustainable access to affordable credit — and improving over time?
Progress matters more than static risk.
7. Reduction in Financial Stress and Increased Financial Confidence
Do members feel more capable, confident, and in control of their financial lives?
Confidence is not soft. It is predictive.
These seven outcomes are not product categories.
They are stability indicators.
They reflect whether credit unions are improving the conditions that allow people to participate fully in economic life.
If the cooperative model exists to improve financial lives, these are the lives we should be measuring.
Why This Anchoring Matters Now
Today’s financial ecosystem favors institutions that can:
Demonstrate differentiated value
Show measurable outcomes
Translate mission into evidence
AI and advanced analytics have raised expectations.
Regulators expect transparency.
Policymakers expect accountability.
Communities expect proof.
Relevance is no longer a narrative.
It is a capability.
And that capability begins with deciding what truly matters enough to measure.
A Consideration for Leaders
What would change if credit unions aligned strategy, data, AI, product development, and advocacy around measurable improvement in these seven conditions?
What would change if boards regularly reviewed not only growth metrics, but stability metrics?
What would change if credit unions could demonstrate, consistently and comparably, that members are more stable, more resilient, and more confident because they exist?
Relevance would no longer be assumed.
It would be evident.
And when relevance is evident, independence becomes protectable.
The Leadership Question
The cooperative model has always been about more than financial services.
It has been about improving lives.
The challenge of this moment is not whether credit unions still hold that mission.
The challenge is whether they can demonstrate it clearly enough to protect it.
If you would like to explore this framework more deeply, I invite you to download:
The 2-page abstract provides a concise overview
Because credit unions will not remain relevant by explaining who they are.
They will remain relevant by proving what they change.
Credit unions do meaningful work every day—but those stories often live in silos.
CU Power Points is a living collection of impact moments that make the value of credit unions easier to see, reflect on, and learn from.
👉 Explore CU Power Points. Submit your own!
Click 👆🏻 on the image to learn more and access the white paper.
Your Board. Your Strategy. Future-Ready.
The future of credit unions is data-driven—and that future begins in the boardroom. THRIVE’s Board Strategy Workshops help unlock alignment and accelerate your leadership’s journey toward impactful decisions. These customized sessions guide boards beyond passive oversight into confident enablers of innovation, simplifying AI and analytics for real-world applications.
If your leadership is ready to shift from “data stuck” to “data smart”—fast—this is for you. Curious? Let’s build your next board strategy together. Learn more here.
Comments